Friday, September 14, 2007

Nations and Tribes...When Will WE Learn?

"Great powers never should involve themselves in
the political disputes of small tribes."
Kamil Salibi, Lebanese historian

























I remember watching Lawrence of Arabia a long time ago. It was one of my mother's favorite movies, and it is an epic film to learn much from. After reading Thomas L. Friedman's op-ed piece discussing the Chinese and American worldview, I couldn't help thinking about that movie again. Friedman says, "...over the last 6 years, China prepared for the Olympics while we built up an immense national debt buying Ipods and fighting Al-Qaeda."

Later, Friedman relates an incident he heard about from an American officer. His
unit was on patrol in a Sunni neighborhood when it was hit by an IED. A Black Hawk helicopter was in the area and alerted the soldiers on the ground that a man was escaping on a bicycle. The helicopter then used its generated wind to knock the insurgent off the bike. As Friedman writes, "the image of a $6 million helicopter being used for this captures the absurdity of our situation in
Iraq."

The map to the right illustrates the ethnic make-up of the country that Bush's general has us staying in for the indeterminable future. I can only hope that the next president, and the present Congress, take a look at Peter O'Toole and his classic role as a British hero and realist in an ancient world of tribes, hatred, and sand.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Good point, daddyday - we won't learn from the British mistakes after WWI. Though, Thomas Friedman wants to have it both ways. He advocated for this war vociferously and basically said it would be easy and so important to have a "democracy" in the middle east.

He wants us to forget he put his credibility on the line and now in my view it is malignant.

Anonymous said...

True,in the article he refers to that standpoint. i have always been skeptical of him, and I really wrote more about his quote from the Lebanese historian and when i read Friedman announcing that he was wrong, and refreshed by the Chinese viewpoint, I felt torn by someone who writes like he believes everything is going to be OK, and when it doesnt exactly go according to plan, turns the tables on himself. But, on the other had, he at least has the courage to admit that he was wrong. Which is more than almost anybody in political power today.

Anonymous said...

yeah, I did not know that he admitted that. Definitely good for him.